top of page
Search

The Essential Guide to Finding the Right Therapist: 3 Things You Must Know

  • Writer: Sam Rothrock
    Sam Rothrock
  • Aug 4
  • 4 min read

Finding the right therapist can transform your mental health journey. Here's the knowledge you need to make the best choice.


Choosing a therapist is one of the most important decisions you can make. It impacts your mental health and personal growth. Many people enter therapy without understanding what makes the relationship effective. Here are 3 things to consider when seeking the right therapist.


The knowledge gained from understanding these criteria save you time, money, and energy. It ensures you get the most out of your therapeutic investment. Let's explore these elements that separate transformative therapy from feeling stuck.


The Foundation of Great Therapy: Easy Communication


Are They Easy to Talk To?

The first and most fundamental quality to look for in a therapist is whether they're easy to talk to. This might seem obvious, but don't underestimate this. You should discuss your life, problems, victories, and struggles without fear.


From the very first session, you should sense that your therapist wants to hear what you have to say. This doesn't mean you'll spill your deepest secrets on day one—that takes time. You should immediately feel safety that allows for authentic communication.


The Churchill-Moran Relationship

Consider the relationship between Winston Churchill and his personal physician, Lord Moran. While not a therapist, Moran served as Churchill's confidant during World War II. Churchill felt comfortable sharing his fears, anxieties, and strategic concerns with him. Moran created an environment free from judgment. This openness helped Churchill manage the pressure of leading a country through war.


Exercise: The Communication Comfort Test

To know whether your therapist meets this criterion, try this:


The 10-Minute Reflection:

  1. Set a timer for 10 minutes after each session

  2. Write down how you felt while speaking to your therapist

  3. Rate your comfort level on a scale of 1-10

  4. Note any moments when you held back or felt judged

  5. Track patterns over 3-4 sessions

If you score below 7, or notice yourself holding back, it may be time to consider other options.


Two people meeting casually on  a couch.

Beyond Hearing: Active Understanding

The Difference Between Hearing and Listening

The second critical quality involves your therapist's ability to understand you. There's a profound difference between hearing and listening with the intent to understand.


Active listening means not only paying attention but demonstrating that attention. They communicate through responses, questions, and body language. They're trying to see the world through your eyes. There's no "right" perspective—only your lived experience.


Nelson Mandela's Leadership Approach

Nelson Mandela exemplified this quality of understanding others' perspectives. Hi didn't only hear his from former oppressors. Mandela understood their fears, concerns, and viewpoints. This approach enabled him to build bridges and create lasting change. A great therapist employs this same skill. They seek to understand your world rather than impose their interpretation.


Exercise: The Understanding Assessment

Practice this evaluation technique to determine if your therapist understands you:


The Mirror Test:

  1. Ask your therapist to summarize what they heard

  2. Pay attention to whether they capture not only the facts, but the emotions and nuances

  3. Notice if they ask clarifying questions that show genuine curiosity about your experience

  4. Observe whether they reflect back your feelings.

  5. Score their understanding: Does it feel like they "get" you?


A therapist who demonstrates understanding will help you feel heard and validated. It creates the foundation for meaningful progress. Carl Rogers claimed that no one makes progress without acceptance first!



Casual conversation

Connecting Your Dots

The Power of Pattern Recognition

The third essential quality separates good therapists from transformative ones. The ability to provide insight by connecting patterns in your life. Your therapist should recognize habits, behaviors, and responses you might not see.


They should identify connections between your past and present. A therapist can connect similar behaviors from different circumstances. They can say something like, "I notice that every time you face a stressful situation, you respond in this way." Then help you understand why.


Historical Example: Steve Jobs and Self-Awareness

Steve Jobs demonstrated remarkable self-awareness. He recognized patterns in his behavior. How perfectionism drove innovation and created a toxic work environment. This insight allowed him to change his approach while maintaining his high standards. A skilled therapist helps you achieve similar breakthrough moments of self-recognition.


Exercise: The Pattern Journal

Create your own insight-tracking system to work alongside your therapeutic process:


The Weekly Pattern Review:

  1. Keep a daily journal noting your emotional responses to different situations

  2. Each week, review your entries looking for recurring themes

  3. Identify triggers that produce similar responses

  4. Note any insights your therapist has shared about these patterns

  5. Practice connecting past experiences to current behaviors

  6. Celebrate moments when you catch yourself in old patterns before acting


This practice not only helps you check your therapist's insight. It also develops your self-awareness skills.



Journal and Pen

The Timeline of Therapeutic Progress

Understanding the timeline for these qualities is crucial. You should feel comfortable communicating from day one. Know that deeper comfort will develop over time. The sense of being understood should emerge early. Insights and pattern recognition might take longer. Expect meaningful connections every 2-3 sessions rather than in every meeting.


Building Your Therapeutic Alliance

Remember that therapy is a collaborative process. Your therapist should show these 3 things. You also play a role in creating an effective relationship. Come prepared. Be honest and stay curious about yourself. Remain open to new perspectives.


Red Flags to Watch For

If after 4-6 sessions you don't feel comfortable. You sense that your therapist doesn't understand you. If you haven't gained any new insights about yourself in over a month, it may be time to consider other options. Trust your instincts—you know when something isn't working.


The Cost of the Wrong Fit

Staying with the wrong therapist can be more than ineffective. It can be counterproductive. You deserve a therapeutic relationship that promotes growth rather than stagnation.


Taking Action: Your Next Steps

Armed with this knowledge, you're prepared to make informed decisions about your care. These 3 things provide a roadmap for the support you deserve.

Remember, the right therapeutic relationship can be life-changing. Take the time to find the right therapist. One who creates safety, demonstrates understanding, and provides valuable insights. Your journey is too important to settle for anything less than transformative care.


The investment you make in finding the right therapeutic fit will pay dividends. Trust the process and trust your instincts. Remember that the perfect therapeutic fit is out there.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page